Control Has a Price Now

Happy Monday. Last week's nuclear verdict isn't going away quietly, and what it set off will ripple through the entire industry.

Plus:

• The Freight Market Just Started Rebalancing

• New Tariffs Were Built to Survive a Legal Challenge

• Your Logistics Partner Could Be a Cartel Front

💡 QUESTION OF THE DAY:

C.H. Robinson's entire auto liability coverage limit is $___ million.

🍳 WHAT’S COOKIN’ IN FREIGHT

📊 The Freight Market Just Started Rebalancing. ACT Research's June For-Hire Trucking Index shows the tightest freight market in years starting to answer back: the Capacity Index hit a 43-month high of 55.0, up from 53.5 in May, as fleets respond to accelerating rates. Volume slipped 1.8 points to 65.9, still among the strongest readings in the survey's 17-year history, while the Supply-Demand Balance eased to 60.9 from May's 64.2. Class 8 sales remain below replacement levels, but ACT's Carter Vieth says capacity expansion should keep accelerating as spot rate gains flow into contract rates. Driver availability ticked up, which Vieth credits to record driver pay packages.

🌐 New Tariffs Were Built to Survive a Legal Challenge. The Trump administration replaced its expiring 10% global tariff, which ran under emergency powers the Supreme Court struck down, with a new Section 301 regime covering 60 economies and 99.4% of U.S. imports, effective Friday. Legal experts say Section 301 is harder to unwind than the tariff it replaced. For most trucking lanes, the rate barely changed: Mexico, Canada, and USMCA-qualifying freight stay in the same 10% bucket. The real shift hits 38 other economies at 12.5%, including China and Vietnam, hitting ocean and drayage harder than long-haul. China, Australia, Brazil, and Norway are contesting the legal basis.

🚨Your Logistics Partner Could Be a Cartel Front. Treasury's OFAC sanctioned more than 50 people and companies tied to the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, the largest package aimed at the group. One of them, Transic Logistic, is allegedly controlled by Alma Laura Mena Alvarado and Jose Mora Leon, the same pair Treasury says used a petroleum company to steal gasoline in cartel territory while running liquid fentanyl through Transic's freight operation. The list also hit two tequila producers and a baby shoe manufacturer allegedly owned by a CJNG leader. Treasury named Juan Carlos Gonzalez, "Pelón," as CJNG's new leader, with a $5 million reward for his capture.

PRESENTED BY OTR SOLUTIONS

Source carriers with confidence and reduce fraud exposure with OTR Select.

With OTR Select’s capacity tool, brokers can tap into a network of 20,000+ carriers that have been vetted on entry and continuously monitored.

OTR Solutions’ carrier network helps brokers make more confident sourcing decisions with reliable, trustworthy capacity backed by a low 0.3% claims rate.

What C.H. Robinson's Verdict Actually Exposed

A Dallas jury awarded $604 million against C.H. Robinson, carrier Lupus Superior, and driver Gorgonio Gonzalez on Friday, over a fatal 2021 crash in Mississippi that killed three people.

On the night of the crash, Gonzalez called both companies to say he was too sick to keep driving. Rather than rescheduling, C.H. Robinson let him continue anyway, plaintiffs argued.

Dispatching Becomes Evidence

The jury found Gonzalez was "operating the vehicle in the furtherance of a mission for the benefit of C.H. Robinson and subject to control by C.H. Robinson as to the details of the mission," language from the judge's charge.

This isn't the first case decided on the extent of a broker's control. A 2011 case upheld a verdict against C.H. Robinson because it dispatched a driver directly and required daily check calls.

A 2023 Illinois ruling shows the opposite: a 3PL was dismissed from an $18 million verdict for exercising no control over hiring, firing, or dispatching.

Rob Carpenter, a broker-liability expert witness, ties the numbers together: the jury set C.H. Robinson's own share at $139 million, but the control finding is what could add Gonzalez's 45% share to that bill. C.H. Robinson disputes it: 'no valid legal theory allows' extending liability that way.

What FMCSA Won't Show

The Transportation Intermediaries Association (TIA) is fighting over the safety rating. President Chris Burroughs confirmed Lupus Superior held a Satisfactory rating since 2014, reaffirmed in April.

What it missed: the carrier had crossed FMCSA's intervention threshold in Unsafe Driving and Hours-of-Service Compliance, an internal trigger FMCSA doesn't publish.

Since the 2015 FAST Act, the FMCSA can't release percentile rankings or comparisons of violations to peers for any category. Brokers can review raw violation counts, public for five of seven; two, including Crash Indicator, stay hidden regardless.

"The jury was given access to data...not available to the public, including brokers," Burroughs said. TIA has petitioned FMCSA for a public high-risk list since May. FMCSA hasn't ruled on it.

Beyond The Stock Drop

C.H. Robinson shares fell 10.78% over the week the verdict landed, with RXO down 7.71% and Landstar off 3.68% on Friday alone.

But the reaction that matters more isn't on the trading floor. C.H. Robinson's auto liability program is a $10 million retention under $135 million in limits, a tower that sell-side analysts flagged Friday as thin enough that even a reduced settlement exhausts it.

Most brokers don't carry anything close to that: the federal bond requirement is just $75,000, and few brokers carry the kind of excess liability coverage that would respond to a catastrophic negligent-hiring verdict.

Carpenter says the real reaction is inside underwriting departments, not Wall Street: "Insurance is about to become the enforcement mechanism the safety rating system never was."

PRESENTED BY GOODSHIP

Brokerages are sitting on valuable network insight, they just can't access them easily.

GoodShip helps logistics service providers identify where customer commitments are breaking down, where customers are shipping more than expected, which transactional lanes deserve a contract strategy, and where lane imbalances are creating opportunities.

 🌎 AROUND THE FREIGHT WEB

🌉 The Gordie Howe Bridge Finally Opens Today. The $6.4 billion bridge connecting Windsor and Detroit opens years behind schedule, and a fresh 50% tariff threat scrapped the joint U.S.-Canada celebration everyone had planned.

🚨 $346K Found After a Skipped Scale. Michigan troopers pulled a 2023 Freightliner registered to a Tennessee company after it skipped an I-75 scale, and found 97 kilograms of marijuana and vacuum-sealed cash in the sleeper.

🚛 2022 Trucks Aren't New Enough. One carrier says brokers moving server freight for Dell, Microsoft, and Tesla are getting picky on equipment: his four 2022 trucks with around 640,000 miles have until September before those same brokers stop letting him pick up.

📉 A USPS Contractor Filed Bankruptcy. Eagle Logistics, a 151-truck carrier running a dedicated USPS route between Florida and New Jersey, filed Chapter 11 with under $50,000 in assets against millions in liabilities, one of ten freight-sector bankruptcies filed in a two-week span.

🍌 A Banana Shipment Just Became a $290M Bust. Italian authorities found nearly 1,700 pounds of cocaine hidden among banana pallets in a refrigerated container running one of the busiest South America-to-Europe produce lanes.

🎣 THE FREIGHT MAGAZINE

Issue 003 of FreightCaviar Print is here.

From $17/month.

30-day money-back guarantee. If it's not for you, we'll refund you right away, and you still keep both Winter and Spring editions.

Subscribe →here.

😂 FREIGHT HUMOR

🎧 THE FREIGHT CAVIAR PODCAST

Terminal Manager at Erives Enterprises, Mario Torres, joined Paul-Bernard Jaroslawski on the FreightCaviar Podcast to discuss why cross-border freight remains a steady bet despite tariffs, how Juarez has evolved into a high-tech manufacturing powerhouse, what keeps freight moving across the U.S.-Mexico border, and more.

Watch it on YouTube, or listen to the full episode on Spotify and Apple Podcasts.